The best hide tanning solution is the one that fits the job on your bench. Some need a salt cure and an acid pickle first and some don't; the same goes for an oil after the tan. Below, the common products compared: alum and aluminum sulfate, Lutan FN, McKenzie Tan, Liqua Tan, Curatan, Krowtann and a one-step pickle-and-tan powder, with what each needs, costs and demands for safety.
What kinds of hide tanning solution are there?
Tanning changes the hide itself. In the EPA's account, a tanning agent reacts chemically with the hide's collagen fibers. Chrome and bark tannins are the agents U.S. tanneries use most, and the EPA also names alum and "syntans (man-made chemicals)" (EPA AP-42, section 9.15). Mississippi State Extension notes that commercial leather is widely made with chrome tanning, while vegetable tannins usually take a long time to work (Mississippi State Extension).
Grouped by how you use them:
- Alum salts. Potassium alum, ammonium alum and aluminum sulfate, used as a paste or a soak.
- Submersion tans over a pickle. Lutan FN: the skin soaks in a tan bath.
- Brushed or rubbed on over a pickle. McKenzie Tan is brushed on, Liqua Tan and Curatan go on by brush or gloved hand, and Syn-Oil is rubbed in with latex gloves.
- Shortcut tans. Krowtann 2000 skips the salting step and the pH checks, and with ATS Pickle-Tan A-21, one bath handles both steps.
For hair-off buckskin, see our guide to brain tanning deer hide.
How do the tanning chemicals compare?
The table sums up each maker's directions; follow the sheet that ships with yours.
| Product | Salt and pickle first? | How it goes on | Oil after? | Timing (maker's figure) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lutan FN | Yes. Pickle at pH 1.5 to 2.0 for 72 hours or more, then neutralize | Soak in a tan bath held at pH 3.5 to 4 | Yes: 2 parts hot water to 1 part leather oil | Small game or a well-shaved deer cape: 12 to 24 hours; never over 48 |
| McKenzie Tan | Yes. 3 days in a pH 1.0 to 2.0 pickle, then shave and neutralize | Brushed on the damp flesh side | Optional extra oil for dry tans (Amy's Taxidermy) | Rolled up 4 to 5 hours, then washed and towel dried |
| Liqua Tan | Yes. Two days or more in a pH 1.8 to 2.2 pickle, then neutralize to a skin pH of 4.5 to 5.0 | Brushed or worked in by gloved hand | Optional softening oil 12 to 18 hours later | Can be mounted after 8 hours (overnight preferred), or dried |
| Curatan | Yes, salt and pickle | Brushed or rubbed on, skin left flesh side up | None given in the Hide Tanning directions | 70 to 80 degree F room; light skins ready to check at 8 to 10 hours |
| Krowtann 2000 | Neither salt nor pH checks | Rough flesh, then soak | Not required; Krow-Oil sold for rugs | Soak 3 to 4 days |
| Pickle-Tan A-21 (ATS) | One powder for both steps | Bath | Yes, ATS Fur Oil | Not given on the seller's page |
| Potassium alum | Not required | Salt, alum and water mixed into a paste | Yes; small skins for mounting get a saturated borax soak instead | Knead in a bag daily for a week |
| Ammonium alum | Optional; a pickle first gives softer leather | Per the included instructions | Yes, always | Per the included instructions |
Sources: Van Dyke's Lutan FN Kit Instructions, McKenzie Tan kit instructions, Liqua Tan acid pickle method, Hide Tanning (Curatan), Krowtann 2000, Potassium Alum and Ammonium Alum; F&T Fur Harvester's Trading Post (A-21) and its Fur Oil page; Amy's Taxidermy, 2023.
Do you have to pickle before you tan?
For most commercial tans, yes. Van Dyke's says that for Lutan FN, Syn-Oil and Liqua Tan, and Curatan, "you must salt and pickle" before the tan (Van Dyke's, Hide Tanning). Its Liqua Tan FAQ admits the tan will work on a skin that was never cured but advises against it: the cure was skipped, and whatever blood and untannable protein remains works against a proper tan (Van Dyke's, Liqua Tan FAQ).
Two products and the alums change that rule. Van Dyke's describes Krowtann 2000 as needing "no salting, no oiling and no ph checks." Its soak in the mixed tan lasts 3 to 4 days, bracketed by a rough fleshing beforehand and the final fleshing after, and a neutralizing wash readies it for the form (Van Dyke's, Krowtann 2000). One powder, Advanced Tanning Solutions' Pickle-Tan A-21, "pickles and tans all in one," says F&T Fur Harvester's Trading Post (F&T, Pickle-Tan A-21). And Van Dyke's says alums can tan a hide without a pickle, though a pickle first "produces plumper softer leather" (Van Dyke's, Ammonium Alum).
The pickles themselves differ too. Knobloch's Safety Pickle is sold as a pickling acid that, unlike a formic acid pickle, doesn't give off fumes or vapors; it's held at pH 1.8 to 2.2, and its directions say to test the skin rather than the bath, since the skin trails the solution (Van Dyke's, Knoblochs Safety Pickle). The Liqua Tan acid pickle page advises against mineral acids, naming hydrochloric and sulfuric. For the full salting, pickling and neutralizing sequence, see our guide to tanning hides.
Which tans need oil afterward?
Submersion tans and alum do, and the brush-on tans vary. Amy, a North Carolina taxidermist, says in her tanning tutorial that submersion tans such as Lutan F or EZ-100 need "an additional oiling after the tanning process," and she mixes her leather oil two parts water to one part oil (Amy's Taxidermy, 2023). The Lutan FN sheet gives the same 1 to 2 mix, with hot water (Lutan FN Kit Instructions).
Van Dyke's is blunt about alum: "Always oil an alum tanned skin to prevent leaching of chemicals!" Its potassium alum directions say to paint the leather side with tanning oil while it's still wet and stretched. For animals up to fox size going on a form, though, it skips the oil and the stretching and uses a 10-minute soak in a saturated borax solution instead (Van Dyke's, Potassium Alum).
Amy treats McKenzie Tan as the oil step: she brushes it on, calls it "tanning oil" when she checks the skins the next day, and adds leather oil afterward when she wants a dry tan even more supple (Amy's Taxidermy, 2023). Liqua Tan's product page says it sets the hair "with no oily mess" (Van Dyke's, Liqua Tan), and its kit adds Tanning Oil #1, applied at the 12 to 18 hour mark after you warm it to 90 to 100 degrees (Van Dyke's, Liqua Tan kit instructions). Van Dyke's says Krowtann needs no oiling, but for a rug, Matuska's Krow-Oil sheet has the oiled skin spend 24 hours folded up (Matuska, Krow Oil instructions).
Is alum tanning as good as a commercial tan?
Alum is cheap, with 5 pounds of ammonium alum listed at $23.50 at Van Dyke's (price list), but it takes more work to get soft, and the Liqua Tan FAQ on Van Dyke's site argues Liqua Tan holds up better. For Mississippi State Extension's salt-alum method, you mix alum, ammonium or potassium, into water at a rate of 1 pound per gallon, then a soda and salt solution goes in and flour thickens it into a paste you spread on in coats over several days. It calls this method "slightly better" than its salt-acid method but warns the skin "is usually harder" and may need more working (Mississippi State Extension).
Van Dyke's calls potassium alum "an excellent tan for skins from rabbit to deer" (Van Dyke's, Potassium Alum). Its paste uses equal volumes of salt, alum and water, sealed in a bag with the skin, which you knead for a quarter hour or more each day over a week. Mississippi State's recipe names "ammonium aluminum sulfate or potassium aluminum sulfate (alum)," while Van Dyke's lists plain aluminum sulfate as its own product, "iron-free," and says it "leaves the hide a natural light color" (Van Dyke's, Aluminum Sulfate). Van Dyke's tips for Liqua Tan recommend aluminum sulfate as a helper for a softer skin and easier shaving (Van Dyke's, Liqua Tan tips).
That durability argument comes from a product FAQ, so weigh it that way. By the FAQ's numbers, Liqua Tan reaches a shrink temperature (its yardstick for tanning quality) of about 176 degrees F, alum only about 160, and alum can "hydrolyze in the skin," creating sulfuric acid that damages it (Liqua Tan FAQ).
One Rokslide member wrote in 2021 that after trying commercial solutions, orange-bottle formula and wet tans, he got his best results with borax and alum mixed into a paste "to the consistency of mashed potatoes," left 7 to 10 days to dry and then sanded (forum post, 2021; follow-up). The description of an Urban Hunterz video lists a bucket, alum, pickling salt, water and a brick that holds the hides down (Urban Hunterz).
Some of the product links below are affiliate links. Taxidermy Hobbyist may earn a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.
If you buy alum outside a taxidermy supplier, check the label says potassium or ammonium alum: compare potassium alum powder on Amazon.
Which tan for a mount, and which for a rug?
Decide the finish before you pick the chemical. A wet tan stays damp and goes on a form or into the freezer; a dry tan is dried and broken soft for a rug or wall hanger (Amy's Taxidermy, 2023). On HuntingNet in 2011, a member who said he was a taxidermist and ran a commercial tannery wrote that he only uses wet tans on mounts, keeps dry tans for rugs and flat hides, and gets "superior stretch" from the wet tan (forum post, 2011).
The McKenzie Tan kit's instructions assume a cape you'll wet-tan and mount, finishing with a skin ready to mount or freeze (McKenzie Tan kit instructions). Liqua Tan's product page leaves it open: dry the skin and treat it as tanned, or mount it the same day (Van Dyke's, Liqua Tan). Lutan FN covers both, with stretching and breaking for rug work or furs (Lutan FN Kit Instructions). For a deer cape specifically, our guide to deer hide tanning covers the hair-on steps, and furbearers are covered in tanning fur pelts.
What do tanning chemicals cost?
Sellers' listed prices, read November 22, 2026.
| Product | Size | Listed price | Seller |
|---|---|---|---|
| McKenzie Tan Tanning Kit (Ultimate Acid plus the tan; enough for two average whitetail capes) | Kit | $26.50 | Van Dyke's kits |
| Potassium Alum Tanning Kit (1 pint Protal plus 5 lb alum; 7 to 10 capes or hides) | Kit | $29.00 | Van Dyke's kits |
| Curatan Kit (Curatan, pickling crystals, baking soda) | Hair on | $35.00 | Van Dyke's kits |
| Lutan FN Kit (one deer cape; add water and salt) | 1 lb | $41.00 | Van Dyke's kits |
| Lutan FN | 5 lb | $42.00 | Van Dyke's chemicals |
| Liqua Tan | Quart | $31.00 | Van Dyke's chemicals |
| Liqua Tan Tanning Kit (tanning oil, Liqua Tan, citric acid crystals) | Kit | $37.95 | Matuska |
| Krowtann 2000 (4 to 5 average deer capes per quart) | Quart | $33.50 | Van Dyke's chemicals |
| Krow-Oil | Not listed | $24.50 | Matuska |
| Pickle-Tan A-21 (ATS) | 5 lb | $40.95 | F&T Fur Harvester's Trading Post |
| Ammonium Alum | 5 lb | $23.50 | Van Dyke's chemicals |
| Aluminum Sulfate | 2 lb | $10.25 | Van Dyke's chemicals |
Van Dyke's notes that Krowtann "can't ship by air or mail" (Van Dyke's, Krowtann 2000). For boxed kits side by side, see our hide tanning kit comparison, or browse a hide tanning kit on Amazon.
What safety gear do tanning chemicals need?
At minimum, wear gloves and eye protection and read each chemical's safety data sheet: the aluminum sulfate sheets below warn of serious eye damage. Two aluminum sulfate safety data sheets carry the "Danger" signal word and hazard statement H318, "Causes serious eye damage" (Core Chem SDS, 2024; Alliance Chemical SDS, 2021). Both call for gloves and eye protection. A potassium alum sheet uses the milder "Warning" with skin and eye irritation and harm if swallowed (Home Science Tools SDS, 2018).
- Liqua Tan. The FAQ recommends a brush or rubber gloves for applying it, since it's mildly acidic, at pH 4.0 to 4.5, with small amounts of solvent, and it offers a safety data sheet on request (FAQ). Van Dyke's Liqua Tan product page carries a California Prop 65 warning for ethyl benzene (Van Dyke's, Liqua Tan).
- Krowtann. Van Dyke's classes it as "Limited Quantity" or "Fully Regulated" for shipping; read the label that comes with it (listing).
- Kids. A trapper education guide on home use of furs says "some tanning materials are dangerous," so a young person shouldn't do this work without an adult keeping watch (Ohio trapper education study guide).
For storage, ventilation and the rest of the bench, see our guide to taxidermy chemicals and safety gear.
Which tanning solution should you pick?
Match the product to the skin and the finish, then follow its sheet exactly:
- A cape for a mount: a pickle-based tan such as Lutan FN, McKenzie Tan or Liqua Tan, kept wet, then mounted or frozen.
- A first small pelt on a budget: potassium alum or a small boxed kit, on a low-value fur first, as the trapper guide suggests.
- No time to salt and pickle: Krowtann 2000, after the scrap-skin test Van Dyke's suggests.
- A deer hide or bigger rug: a kit sized for it, and time to break the skin as it dries. Matuska's Krow-Oil sheet recommends a professional tannery for elk and larger; when you find a taxidermist, ask who does their tanning.
A Hunt Talk member's advice on Lutan-F in 2025 was "follow the instructions" (forum post, 2025). One member wrote in 2015 that he tanned a fox with the McKenzie kit and mostly stuck to its directions, but "didn't really measure ingredients or test pH and things turned out fine" (forum post, 2015), but Amy warns that if you guess your pH, your hides are "very likely going to slip" (Amy's Taxidermy, 2023), so test it.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best tanning solution for hides?
There isn't one for every job. Pick by the finish: a pickle-based tan such as Lutan FN, McKenzie Tan or Liqua Tan, kept wet, for a mount; alum for a cheap first pelt; Krowtann 2000 to skip salting and pH checks.
Is aluminum sulfate the same as alum?
Not quite. Mississippi State Extension's recipe glosses "ammonium aluminum sulfate or potassium aluminum sulfate" as alum, and Van Dyke's sells aluminum sulfate, ammonium alum and potassium alum as separate products.
Do you have to oil a hide after tanning?
It depends on the tan. Van Dyke's says to always oil an alum-tanned skin, and the Lutan FN sheet has you work leather oil in after the tan, while Van Dyke's says Krowtann 2000 needs no oiling.
Sources
- US EPA, AP-42 Section 9.15, Leather Tanning (read November 22, 2026)
- Mississippi State University Extension, Slaughtering and Dressing Rabbits (tanning section; read November 22, 2026)
- Van Dyke's Taxidermy Supply: Hide Tanning; Lutan FN Kit Instructions; McKenzie Tan kit instructions; Liqua Tan acid pickle method; Liqua Tan kit instructions; Liqua Tan FAQ; Liqua Tan tips; Knoblochs Safety Pickle; Potassium Alum; product pages for Krowtann 2000, Liqua Tan, Ammonium Alum, Aluminum Sulfate, McKenzie Tan kit, Lutan FN kit, Potassium Alum kit and Curatan kit; price lists for tanning kits and tanning chemicals (all read November 22, 2026)
- Matuska Taxidermy Supply: Krow Oil instructions; chemicals and tanning oils (read November 22, 2026)
- F&T Fur Harvester's Trading Post: Advanced Tanning Solutions' Pickle-Tan A-21 and Fur Oil (read November 22, 2026)
- Safety data sheets: Core Chem, Aluminum Sulfate (2024); Alliance Chemical, Aluminium sulphate (2021); Home Science Tools, Aluminum Potassium Sulfate (2018)
- Kalkomey, Ohio trapper education study guide, Home Use of Furs (read November 22, 2026)
- Amy's Taxidermy, complete tanning tutorial, YouTube, 2023 (transcript read November 22, 2026)
- Urban Hunterz, alum tanning video, YouTube (description read November 22, 2026)
- Forum threads: HuntingNet, wet tan or dry?; Hunt Talk, Tanning you own furs?; Hunt Talk, Tanning a hide on your own; Rokslide, DIY Tanning