LearnBy Taxidermy Hobbyist Editorial TeamUpdated November 22, 2026

How Taxidermy Is Judged: Scoresheets and What Judges Look For

Judged against nature, not against each other

The first thing to understand about taxidermy judging is what your mount is being compared with. In Pennsylvania's rules, it isn't the other entries. It's the live animal, and California likewise ties its ribbons to fixed score bands in its standard categories rather than a ranking.

The Pennsylvania Taxidermist Association's rulebook says each entry is judged on its own merit against a perfect score, which it describes as "Mother Nature rather than against each other" (PTA competition rules). In practice the judge holds your piece up against how a real whitetail, mallard or bass looks. That's why one category can hand out a stack of blue ribbons in a strong year and none in a weak one.

Head-to-head judging does exist. Best of Show, Best of Category and the special divisions pick winners from a field: collective artist pieces, and under the National Taxidermists Association's 2026 rules, live mounting and its Distinguished Taxidermist division. But the score that decides your ribbon is your piece against the standard.

A note on dates: the NTA rules quoted on this page are its 55th Annual (2026) rules, which the NTA keeps online for reference until the 2027 rulebook is published (NTA competition rules).

What a score means

Pennsylvania and California tie each ribbon to a score band, the NTA gives medallions only at 90 points or more, and Virginia sets a 90-point floor for its top awards. The bands are similar but not identical, so read the rules for the show you're entering:

AssociationFirstSecondThirdNotes
Pennsylvania (PTA)90%80%70%Multiple awards in a category, except Collective Artist
California (CAT)90 to 100, blue80 to 89, red70 to 79, whiteOpen class adds 65 to 69 honorable mention, green; see the novice note below
National Taxidermists AssociationMedallions only at 90 or moreBest of Show also needed at least 90 under the 2026 rules
Virginia (VTA)Ribbon bands not given in the rules we readA mount needs 90 or better to qualify for Judges Choice Best in Category and the major awards
Canadian (CTA)No numeric score; ranked 1st+, 1st, 1st- down to 3rd-Judges assign a ribbon ranking instead of points

Sources: PTA, CAT rules, revised 1-2024, NTA, VTA rules, amended April 2025, CTA.

Rulebooks aren't always tidy. California's own rules give two different novice scales: the placement table puts a novice first place at 90 to 100, while the section on novice and junior levels says 85 to 100. If a band matters to you, ask the competition chair before the show.

At three of the shows we checked, you keep the paper. Pennsylvania returns score sheets to competitors, New York hands them to the competitor to keep (UTNY rules), and the Canadian rules give a score sheet for each entry showing division, category and any qualifying awards, with the judge's critique noted. Under the NTA's 2026 rules each judge initialed the score and the association kept an electronic record for at least a year (NTA competition rules). Commercial divisions are different: Pennsylvania's use no score sheets, New York's give no detailed score sheet, and neither awards Best of Category.

What judges look at

None of the association pages we read publishes a line-by-line breakdown of its score sheet, so treat any exact point values you hear for eyes or ears as one show's sheet, not a rule. What the rules do name:

  • Correctness of the specimen. The NTA scores its top division for "correctness of specimen, taxidermy craftsmanship and degree of difficulty" (NTA divisions). Its clay sculpture division is judged on correctness of anatomy and locomotion and on whether the sculpture is ready for industry use.
  • Artistry for the top awards. For Taxidermist of the Year, the NTA's 2026 rules had the judge panel weigh artistic merit, composition, visual impact, how difficult the piece is, and the quality of the taxidermy itself.
  • The result, not the method. Pennsylvania tells its judges to judge the finished result rather than how it was achieved, a rule it ties to keeping judges from prejudging freeze-dried specimens.
  • Everything they need must be visible. Under the NTA's 2026 rules, an entry could be ruled ineligible if too many judging points were hidden or left out; the example given was a single wood duck head poking out of a tree hole.

The inspection is close. A 2019 feature on the World Taxidermy Championships showed a judge shining a flashlight into the eye of a mounted bison (The Star, August 2019). Compare that with the commercial divisions some shows run to critique average customer work: Pennsylvania judges those from a distance with no flashlights, magnifying glasses or touching; the Canadian association judges them from 5 feet back; New York judges them without a flashlight or touch (UTNY divisions). In the regular divisions, expect the close look.

One forum comment on a competition bobcat points to the face. Commenting on it in 2022, one Hunt Talk member wrote that "Most taxidermists' cats never look quite right in the face", and that the difference is "in the nose and the depth of the eyes" (Hunt Talk, August 2022). That's one member, not a judge, but the eyes and nose are where a close look starts.

You can help the judge see your work. The NTA's 2026 rules let competitors provide photos showing form alterations and parts they made themselves, and Pennsylvania lets you leave notes on originality with the entry for the judge.

Fatal flaws and disqualifications

A fatal flaw is a problem bad enough that a piece doesn't place at all. Definitions differ:

  • Under the NTA's 2026 rules, a fatal-flaw piece still got its score sheet, though it couldn't win a ribbon or award, and a mount with an offensive odor was removed and not judged.
  • The Canadian rules list major anatomical inaccuracies, wet specimens and improper preservation among fatal flaws; those entries aren't judged and fees aren't refunded. Novice entries there have no fatal flaws, which is a real kindness to first-timers.
  • Pennsylvania removes fatal-flawed or offensive pieces, odor included, without refunding the entry fee.

Rules violations are a separate risk. Identifying plaques or signs must be removed or covered before judging at the Canadian and New York shows, and the NTA's 2026 rules barred any competitor identification on the entry. Pennsylvania, New York and Virginia restrict re-entering a piece that has already been in one of their shows, and so did the NTA's 2026 rules, which let a live mounting piece come back finished. Virginia disqualifies any entry that breaks its rules, as the NTA's 2026 rules did.

Why judges disagree

The same mount can do very differently at two shows. A Hunt Talk member's bobcat drew praise from other members, and one of them noted it didn't take home a ribbon at the 2022 Missouri show. Its owner replied that it got a blue at the Iowa competition that year, and his explanation was simple: "Different judges see things differently." (Hunt Talk, August 2022)

The associations know it. California's rules note that interpretive and novelty entries swing widely in score from judge to judge, and keep them out of awards decided on anatomical accuracy. Challenge rules vary: Virginia charges a $25 challenge fee for a re-judge, the NTA's 2026 rules had no formal score sheet protest, and Pennsylvania wants a written complaint within an hour of the competition room opening, and a re-judge there costs double the entry fee. Judges' decisions are final in Pennsylvania and New York, and in Virginia the second judging is final.

How to use your critique

The score sheet tells you where points went. The critique tells you why, and it's the part to chase. At the 2026 NTA show, judges held critiques on the Saturday afternoon, booked on sign-up sheets, and the association used volunteer members to judge Novice and Youth entries so there was more time for detailed critiques. Pennsylvania says it makes every effort to have judges available one-on-one.

Go in with the piece's reference photos, ask the judge to show you each deduction on the mount, and write it down. Then compare it with your own checklist; our guide to taxidermy critique and common beginner mistakes covers how to check eyes, ears, lips and nose against photos of the live animal. If you haven't competed yet, our guide for the novice taxidermy competition entrant walks through choosing a division. For how judging works at the very top level, see the world taxidermy championship page, and for the full picture of shows and divisions, every kind of taxidermy contest is covered in our competitions guide.

Frequently asked questions

What score do you need for a blue ribbon?

In Pennsylvania, 90%. California's placement table gives blue at 90 to 100 (its novice section says 85).

Do you get your score sheet back?

In the regular divisions at Pennsylvania, New York and the Canadian show, yes. Pennsylvania returns them, New York gives them to the competitor to keep, and the Canadian association gives a sheet for each entry. Commercial divisions there are the exception: Pennsylvania's use no score sheets and New York's give no detailed one.

Can you challenge a judge's score?

It depends on the show. Virginia allows a re-judge for a $25 fee, Pennsylvania takes a written protest within an hour of the competition room opening and can have the piece re-judged for double the entry fee, and the NTA's 2026 rules had no formal challenge process.

Are freeze-dried mounts allowed?

It depends on the show. Pennsylvania judges the result rather than the method, New York puts freeze-dried pieces in their own open category apart from turkey heads, and the Canadian association doesn't accept freeze-dried specimens, though freeze-dried parts on a conventional mount are allowed.

Need a Professional?

Browse taxidermy studios, schools, suppliers and tanneries by state.

Find a Taxidermist Near You