McKenzie: The Elephant in the Room
McKenzie Taxidermy Supply is the largest taxidermy supplier in North America. They're the default choice because they're everywhere, they stock everything, and they've been around forever. That doesn't automatically make them the best—it makes them the safe choice.
This is an honest review: where McKenzie excels, where they're just adequate, and whether their prices justify the reputation.
Product Range: Literally Everything
Foam Forms
McKenzie carries forms for virtually every species, from mice to moose, including extinct and exotic animals. Their selection is unmatched. Multiple size variants for common species ensure proper proportions.
Quality: Closed-cell foam, anatomically accurate, consistent quality across products. Their forms rarely show defects or manufacturing inconsistencies.
Pricing: $60–$150 for common species depending on size. Premium species cost more. Not the cheapest, but quality justifies price.
The workhorses—what actually sells:
- For beginners: McKenzie's generic deer head forms ($90–$110) and upland game bird forms ($65–$85) are consistent sellers. These are forgiving to mount, use standard glass eyes, and teach proper technique without demanding anatomical perfection. The 1/2 and 3/4 life-size variants get more attention than full-size when hobbyists are learning.
- For experienced taxidermists: The full-size deer variants (different ear positions and facial structures), bobcat forms, and waterfowl body forms move consistently. Professionals also purchase specialty forms regularly—bears, felines, and less-common upland game—because McKenzie stocks depth across rare species where competitors stock only common ones.
Reality: If a form exists for your species, McKenzie likely stocks it. This alone explains their dominance.
Glass Eyes
McKenzie carries eyes from multiple manufacturers (Tohickon, Paas-Bergen, proprietary collections). Their eye inventory includes thousands of color and size combinations.
Range: $2–$25 per pair depending on quality level. From basic molded eyes to hand-painted premium options.
The practical choices—what performers use:
- For beginners: McKenzie's mid-range molded eyes in dark amber and black ($4–$7 per pair) are the entry point. These are forgiving under slight pressure errors, work across deer and game birds, and teach eye-setting without making poor technique obvious. The 12mm and 16mm sizes cover 80% of beginner projects.
- For experienced taxidermists: The hand-painted premium eyes from Tohickon ($15–$25) get purchased regularly for high-end mounts. Professionals also stock mid-range hand-painted eyes ($8–$12) because they improve realism without requiring perfect technical work. Experienced taxidermists focus on 2–3 trusted eye types rather than browsing the full catalog.
Reality: Overkill selection for most hunters. You probably don't need 47 shades of amber. But if you want a specific color and size, McKenzie likely has it.
Ear Liners and Components
McKenzie manufactures or distributes the broadest selection available. Standard plastic, pre-painted, hair-covered, custom options.
Pricing: $5–$30 per pair depending on type. Quality is consistent.
Reality: Wide selection means less searching. You find what you need quickly.
Adhesives and Chemical Systems
McKenzie formulates proprietary adhesive lines designed specifically for taxidermy. These include foam-safe, hide-bonding, and eye-setting formulas.
Quality: Formulated to professional standards. They work reliably without damaging materials.
Pricing: $15–$30 per container. Mid-range compared to alternatives.
Reality: Their proprietary formulas are solid. Generic adhesives often underperform. This is where McKenzie's engineering adds real value.
Tools and Instrumentation
Complete tool sets from beginner ($75–$150) to professional ($200–$500). Individual specialized instruments available.
Quality: Professional-grade tools that last decades. Sharp blades, precise forceps, durable handles. For more details, see our tools overview.
The kits that move:
- For beginners: McKenzie's basic carving and eye-setting kits ($100–$130) are consistent starters. These include sculpting tools, forceps, and detail knives without overwhelming the new taxidermist with specialty instruments they won't use for years. The quality is professional-grade, which means they won't dull in a season or snap under normal use.
- For experienced taxidermists: Individual specialty tools get purchased—clay sculpting sets, advanced eye-setting forceps, and precision detail knives. Professionals build their toolkit gradually, buying specific instruments as projects demand them, rather than buying kits.
Reality: Their tool selection is comprehensive. You can outfit a complete workspace from McKenzie.
Bases and Display Hardware
Wooden plaques in multiple styles and sizes. Composite options. Custom-finished pieces. Mounting hardware and brackets for every application.
Pricing: $20–$150+ depending on material and finish.
Reality: Selection is broad. Quality varies. Some plaques are exceptional, some are adequate.
Pricing Reality: Not the Cheapest, But Worth It
Comparison to Van Dyke's: For more details, see our Van Dyke's comparison.
- Deer form: McKenzie $100–$130 vs. Van Dyke's $80–$110
- Quality eye pair: McKenzie $10–$15 vs. Van Dyke's $6–$12
- Foam-safe adhesive: McKenzie $20 vs. Van Dyke's $15–$18
- Complete beginner kit: McKenzie $100–$150 vs. Van Dyke's $80–$120
The premium: 10–20% higher prices compared to Van Dyke's. You're paying for selection and expert support.
The justification: If you only source one supplier, McKenzie's breadth eliminates shopping around. You pay a selection premium, which can be justified if you value convenience and one-stop shopping.
Honest take: If you're price-sensitive, Van Dyke's often provides better value. If you value having everything available from one source, McKenzie is worth the premium.
Shipping and Availability
Processing: Usually ships within 3–5 business days. Standard for the industry.
Shipping cost: Competitive. Free shipping on orders over $150 (varies by location). Additional fees for Alaska and Hawaii.
Turnaround: Most items arrive within 5–7 business days.
Availability: Online inventory system shows real-time stock. No more ordering out-of-stock items.
Reality: Reliable, professional logistics. No surprises or delays.
Customer Service: The Reputation Check
McKenzie's customer service reputation is legendary within taxidermy circles.
What you get: Expert phone consultation for material selection. Experienced taxidermists on staff to answer technical questions. Video tutorials and instructional content. Generous warranty and return policies.
Reality: Their technical support team actually knows taxidermy. They can guide you through project planning, material selection, and troubleshooting. This service is genuinely valuable and differentiates them from online retailers.
Experience: Many hobbyists contact McKenzie with project questions and receive personalized guidance. This level of support is rare among suppliers.
What McKenzie Does Well
- Unmatched product selection—if it exists in taxidermy, they stock it
- Consistent quality across all product categories
- Expert customer service with real taxidermists available
- Professional-grade materials suitable for any skill level
- Reliable shipping and inventory management
- Educational resources including videos and technical guides
- Established relationships with professionals and schools
Where McKenzie Isn't Perfect
- Slightly higher prices than value-focused competitors (Van Dyke's)
- Overwhelming product catalogs that can paralyze beginners
- Website is functional but not as user-friendly as some alternatives
- Minimum order requirements for wholesale pricing (if you're buying in volume)
- International shipping can be expensive and complicated
- Some product categories are extensive (eyes) when you might only need basic options
Comparison to Direct Competitors
McKenzie vs. Van Dyke's
Van Dyke's is leaner, more value-oriented, and provides exceptional personalized service. McKenzie is broader, more professional-focused, and better for specialized or rare species. If you need everything and want expert support, McKenzie wins. If you want fair prices and personal attention, Van Dyke's wins.
McKenzie vs. Artworks Studios
Artworks specializes in beginner-friendly, budget-focused products. McKenzie serves the full spectrum. Artworks is cheaper for basic projects. McKenzie is better for advanced work. For more details, see our full supplies guide.
McKenzie vs. Specialty Retailers
Specialty retailers (Tohickon for eyes, specific form manufacturers) excel in their niche. McKenzie is your one-stop solution when you don't want to source from multiple suppliers.
Real-World Customer Experience
Professionals and established hobbyists love McKenzie. Beginners sometimes feel overwhelmed by options. The customer service team handles both well—they'll guide beginners toward appropriate selections or provide detailed expertise for professionals.
Processing times are fast. Shipping is reliable. Problems are rare, and returns are handled generously.
What Customers Actually Say
The positive feedback: Experienced taxidermists consistently praise McKenzie's form accuracy and eye selection. Professionals mention that having everything in one catalog eliminates the frustration of sourcing from five different suppliers. Customer service gets universal credit—shop owners note that their sales reps remember project histories and proactively suggest materials. Beginners who get phone support appreciate being steered toward the right product instead of wasting money on premium options they don't need yet.
The common complaints: Budget-conscious hobbyists point out that equivalent products cost less elsewhere. Some beginners report decision paralysis when browsing the full catalog—too many eye colors and form variants. A few customers mention that website navigation could be better; finding specific products sometimes requires calling instead of filtering online. International customers specifically cite shipping costs as prohibitive. Some experienced taxidermists note that McKenzie's premium positioning means they shop competitors first to compare prices on standard items, then return to McKenzie only for specialty pieces.
The realistic take: McKenzie doesn't have many one-star reviews. The negative feedback clusters around price sensitivity and website usability, not product quality. Most complaints come from people who didn't realize McKenzie targets professionals first, hobbyists second, and bargain hunters third.
Who Should Choose McKenzie
McKenzie is right for:
- Professional taxidermists needing comprehensive inventory
- Serious hobbyists planning multiple projects
- Shops requiring reliable wholesale suppliers
- Anyone valuing expert support over lowest price
- Specialists handling unusual or exotic species
- Taxidermy schools and instruction programs
McKenzie might not be best for:
- Budget-conscious beginners (Van Dyke's is cheaper)
- Price-sensitive hobbyists doing one project (shop around)
- Minimalists overwhelmed by product selection
- International customers (shipping is expensive)
Value Proposition: The Real Story
McKenzie charges 10–20% more than some competitors. Are they worth it?
If you: Value expert support, want access to rare items, plan multiple projects, or prefer one-stop shopping, yes.
If you: Are budget-conscious, only need standard items, or are price-sensitive, no. Van Dyke's or specialists offer better value in those scenarios.
Honest assessment: McKenzie isn't "worth more" because their products are objectively superior. They're worth more if you value selection, convenience, and expert support. The premium is for breadth and service, not materials.
Final Take
McKenzie Taxidermy Supply sets the industry standard for a reason: breadth of selection, quality consistency, and professional support. They're not the cheapest, but they're rarely a bad choice. For anyone unsure what they need, McKenzie is the safe default.
For experienced hunters or professionals with specific needs, shopping around might reveal better value. But McKenzie's one-stop convenience and expert support justify their position as the industry leader.
We earn commissions on qualifying purchases through our links.